Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 


SummaryMost relevantAll NewsAnalyst Reco.Other languagesPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector newsMarketScreener Strategies

Supreme Court Weighs Copyright Fight Between Google and Oracle -- 3rd Update

10/07/2020 | 04:27pm EDT

By Brent Kendall

The Supreme Court on Wednesday considered a multibillion-dollar copyright battle between Oracle Corp. and Alphabet Inc.'s Google, with justices appearing to look for a resolution that would retain legal protections for software code without throwing the tech industry into disarray.

The decade-old case centers on Oracle's allegations that Google's Android smartphone-operating system infringed on copyrights related to Oracle's Java platform, which Oracle acquired when it bought Sun Microsystems Inc. in 2010.

During about 90 minutes of oral arguments, the justices considered issues related to how software developers use application-program interfaces, or APIs -- prewritten packages of computer code that allow programs, websites or apps to talk to one another.

Oracle has accused Google of illegally copying more than 11,000 lines of Java API code to develop its Android operating system, which runs more than two billion mobile devices world-wide.

Google's unlicensed use of that code is no better than "if someone wanted to write a book that reproduced the 11,000 best lines of 'Seinfeld'," Oracle lawyer Joshua Rosenkranz told the court.

Mr. Rosenkranz said Microsoft Corp. and Apple Inc. spent billions developing their platform code, and Google should have done so as well. "The Copyright Act does not give Google a pass just because it would be expensive to re-create our expression," he said.

Oracle previously sought as much as $9 billion in damages from Google, though that request is now several years old and is likely to increase if Oracle wins at the high court.

Google lawyer Thomas Goldstein told the court that copyright protections aren't supposed to extend to basic computer code that relates to how software functions. The effect of Oracle's proposed rule "would be to make the creation of innovative computer programs less efficient," he said.

"The long-settled practice of reusing software interfaces is critical to modern interoperable computer software," Mr. Goldstein said. Oracle, he said, was seeking to keep software developers "prisoners" of the Java platform and attempting to "block the publication of millions of programs on an innovative smartphone platform."

Several justices voiced resistance to Google's arguments.

"Cracking the safe may be the only way to get the money that you want, but that doesn't mean you can do it," Chief Justice John Roberts told Mr. Goldstein. If Oracle has the only way to get in, "the way for you to get it is to get a license," the chief justice said.

Mr. Goldstein responded that if Oracle wrote a book about how to crack safes, that wouldn't give the company the exclusive right to open them.

Justice Clarence Thomas had a different analogy, wondering whether Google's position was like using an opposing football team's playbook. Justice Samuel Alito, meanwhile, said that under Google's arguments, "all computer code is at risk of losing protection."

The court, however, also wondered what a win for Oracle would do to a tech world in which developers build new applications that use others' APIs to make their products work. Justice Sonia Sotomayor said Google used less than 1% of the Java code. Justice Stephen Breyer questioned whether Oracle's APIs were like the QWERTY keyboard.

"If you let somebody have a copyright on that now, they would control all typewriters, which really has nothing to do with copyright," Justice Breyer said.

Mr. Rosenkranz said the keyboard was "purely mechanical," not a creative expression like how Oracle wrote its code. "The software industry rose to world dominance since the 1980s because of copyright protection, not unlicensed copying," he said.

The case has attracted widespread attention in tech circles and beyond. Businesses that rely heavily on copyright protections, including in the movie, music and publishing industries, are supporting Oracle, expressing concerns about Google's claims to fair use of content created by others.

Software makers including Microsoft and a leading association of internet companies are supporting Google, saying copyright law must allow some fair use of computer programs to promote follow-on technologies and interoperability between programs.

The Trump administration is supporting Oracle in the case. Justice Department lawyer Malcolm Stewart told the justices that copyright protections provide incentives for companies to invest in developing new code. The tech industry wouldn't face ruin if Google loses, he said.

Google and Oracle had to wait longer than expected for the Supreme Court's consideration: The justices were supposed to hear the case in March, but postponed it when they adjusted their schedule because of the coronavirus pandemic.

A decision is expected by June.

Write to Brent Kendall at brent.kendall@wsj.com

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

10-07-20 1827ET

Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
ALPHABET INC. -1.23% 2403.63 Delayed Quote.38.93%
APPLE INC. -0.87% 130.49 Delayed Quote.-0.68%
LONDON BRENT OIL 0.67% 73.4 Delayed Quote.42.82%
MICROSOFT CORPORATION -0.42% 259.61 Delayed Quote.15.72%
ORACLE CORPORATION -1.41% 76.51 Delayed Quote.19.89%
WTI 1.07% 71.639 Delayed Quote.48.31%
03:38pFed Statement 'Very Bullish' For Tech Stocks, Wedbush Says
06/16Oracle, La-Z-Boy fall; General Motors, Rambus rise
06/16ORACLE  : Plan to Roughly Double Cloud Investments to Boost Fiscal 2022 Sales Wi..
06/16MIDDAY REPORT : Wall Street Little Changed, Awaiting FOMC Outcome
06/16European shares mark record-high close ahead of Fed
06/16Oracle Down Nearly 7%, Worst Performer in S&P 500 So Far Today -- Data Talk
06/16ORACLE  : UBS Adjusts Oracle's Price Target to $79 From $67 Amid 'Defensive Tech..
06/16GLOBAL MARKETS LIVE : Oracle, General Motors, Credit Suisse, Sony, Made.com...
06/16ORACLE  : Evercore ISI Adjusts Oracle PT to $75 From $66, Maintains In Line Rati..
06/16ORACLE  : KeyBanc Adjusts Oracle PT to $90 From $82, Maintains Overweight Rating
More news
Financials (USD)
Sales 2021 40 292 M - -
Net income 2021 12 879 M - -
Net Debt 2021 32 374 M - -
P/E ratio 2021 18,6x
Yield 2021 1,33%
Capitalization 224 B 224 B -
EV / Sales 2021 6,35x
EV / Sales 2022 6,24x
Nbr of Employees 135 000
Free-Float 60,3%
Duration : Period :
Oracle Corporation Technical Analysis Chart | ORCL | US68389X1054 | MarketScreener
Technical analysis trends ORACLE CORPORATION
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus HOLD
Number of Analysts 29
Average target price 76,74 $
Last Close Price 77,56 $
Spread / Highest target 19,9%
Spread / Average Target -1,06%
Spread / Lowest Target -61,3%
EPS Revisions
Managers and Directors
Safra Ada Catz Chief Executive Officer & Director
Lawrence Joseph Ellison Chairman & Chief Technology Officer
Michael J. Boskin Independent Director
Jeffrey S. Berg Independent Director
Naomi O. Seligman Independent Director
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
SAP SE11.32%167 752
INTUIT INC.23.56%129 724
SERVICENOW, INC.-3.64%104 726
DOCUSIGN, INC.17.23%50 776