1. Homepage
  2. Equities
  3. Korea, republic of
  4. Korea Stock Exchange
  5. LG Chem, Ltd.
  6. News
  7. Summary
    A051910   KR7051910008

LG CHEM, LTD.

(A051910)
  Report
SummaryQuotesChartsNewsRatingsCalendarCompanyFinancialsConsensusRevisions 
SummaryMost relevantAll NewsAnalyst Reco.Other languagesPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector newsMarketScreener Strategies

Exclusive: Nissan faces battery plant cuts as electric car hopes fade

09/15/2014 | 02:09am EDT
Pedestrian and cars are reflected in a Nissan Motor logo at the company's dealership in Tokyo

PARIS (Reuters) - Nissan (>> Nissan Motor Co Ltd) boss Carlos Ghosn is preparing to cut battery manufacturing, people familiar with the matter said, in a new reversal on electric cars that has reopened deep divisions with alliance partner Renault (>> RENAULT).

PARIS (Reuters) - Nissan (>> Nissan Motor Co Ltd) boss Carlos Ghosn is preparing to cut battery manufacturing, people familiar with the matter said, in a new reversal on electric cars that has reopened deep divisions with alliance partner Renault (>> RENAULT).

The plan, which faces stiff resistance within the Japanese carmaker, would see U.S. and British production phased out and a reduced output of next-generation batteries concentrated at its domestic plant, two alliance sources told Reuters.

In what may also prove a politically sensitive blow to Japan Inc., Nissan would follow Renault by taking cheaper batteries from South Korea's LG Chem (>> LG Chem Ltd) for some future vehicles, including models made in China.

"We set out to be a leader in battery manufacturing but it turned out to be less competitive than we'd wanted," said one executive on condition of anonymity. "We're still between six months and a year behind LG in price-performance terms."

A decision on the Nissan battery plants in Sunderland, England, and Smyrna, Tennessee, is due next month, the sources said, following a tense procurement review with 43.4 percent shareholder Renault, the smaller but senior partner in their 15-year-old alliance.

"Renault would clearly prefer to go further down the LG sourcing route, and the Nissan engineers would obviously prefer to stay in-house," another insider said. "The write-off costs are potentially huge."

Renault-Nissan "remains 100-percent committed to its industry-leading electric vehicle program" and has no plans to write down battery investments, spokeswoman Rachel Konrad said.

"We have not taken any decision whatsoever to modify battery sourcing allocation," Konrad said, adding that the alliance "does not confirm or deny procurement reviews."

But Nissan is already negotiating with manufacturing partner NEC Corp. (>> NEC Corp) on the shift to dual sourcing, with Chief Executive Ghosn's backing, the sources said. Nissan currently makes all its own electric car batteries.

One option being explored would see LG, which supplies some Renault models, invest in its own battery production at one of the overseas Nissan plants as the carmaker halts operations at the sites.

The alliance is also in talks with LG on a deal to supply batteries for future Renault and Nissan electric models in China, one of the sources added.

NEC and LG declined to comment.

Under Ghosn, who heads both companies, Renault-Nissan bet more on electric cars than any mainstream competitor, pledging in 2009 to invest 4 billion euros ($5.2 billion) to build models including the Nissan Leaf compact and as many as 500,000 batteries per year to power them.

Nissan and NEC invested 23 billion yen ($215 million) in their Zama, Japan battery plant and electrode manufacturing, backed by government aid. U.S. and British taxpayers also helped with the $1 billion invested in Tennessee and 210 million pounds ($341 million) in Sunderland.

But the mass consumer was largely unmoved - or deterred by the sluggish rollout of recharging networks - despite generous sales incentives in key markets.

Global electric car sales will remain shy of 1 million in 2020, according to forecaster IHS Automotive, less than one percent of the total vehicle market, and one-tenth of the demand Ghosn had predicted.

"Renault-Nissan were definitely ahead of their time - in a bad way," said Stuart Pearson, an Exane BNP analyst.

"There's nothing wrong with ambition, but when that involves excess investment then it's also a risk," he said. "Their targets were really excessive on volume and battery capacity."

The alliance has begun a belated push into faster-selling hybrids, combining electric and combustion-engine propulsion. Upscale electric rivals such as Tesla's (>> Tesla Motors Inc) Model S meanwhile hog the limelight, backed by big investments in newer, cheaper battery technologies.

INTERNAL RIVALRIES

Ghosn dropped extra battery sites planned for both alliance carmakers, leaving Nissan with the entire production capacity of 220,000 power packs through the NEC joint venture, AESC.

But that still far exceeds the 67,000 electric cars Renault-Nissan sold last year, and even the 176,000 registered to date. A pledge to reach 1.5 million by 2016 has been scrapped.

The coming hybrids will fill some of the excess plant capacity, although they use fewer power cells per vehicle. An all-electric Tesla rival is still planned for Nissan's premium Infiniti brand in 2018 with batteries as big as 60 kilowatt-hours (kWh), more than twice the energy capacity of the Leaf, which is due for replacement the previous year.

Nissan is seeking to unwind a ruinous NEC contract that requires it to purchase electrodes for the full capacity of 220,000 Leaf-sized 24 kWh batteries regardless of actual sales, sources said. The joint venture partner's consent is also needed to bring LG production or other activities onto the Tennessee or Sunderland sites, which together employ 500 workers.

The financial hit for Nissan "will depend on what else we can do with the plants", with heavy charges likely if both are closed, one manager added.

Renault has already taken at least one writedown of 85 million euros on its over-investment in electric cars following the collapse of Better Place, a charging startup that had ordered 100,000 of its battery-powered Fluence sedans.

The Nissan procurement shift could still be thwarted by capacity-cutting costs including repayment of U.S. and British government support. Next-generation battery manufacturing at Zama would also likely need fresh Japanese aid to compete with LG and its subsidies from Seoul, sources said.

Navigating the battery backtrack is a key test for CEO Ghosn as he demands closer Renault-Nissan integration from executives mandated to pursue savings across the alliance.

For Nissan, the plant cuts would be a partial retreat from the automotive battery market - expected to top $20 billion by 2020 - just as California-based Tesla builds its $5 billion "Gigafactory" with Panasonic (>> Panasonic Corporation) in Nevada.

Japanese engineers are still smarting from Renault's 2010 move to drop Nissan batteries and purchase LG for its flagship Zoe model, worsening the overcapacity problem.

"It was a 15-20 percent cost gap," said one of the people involved in the Renault decision. "In purchasing, 3-4 percent is usually enough to choose a partner for."

Today's Nissan batteries come in at $270 per kWh, based on replacement prices thought to be below cost, according to consulting firm AlixPartners. The true manufacturing cost is believed to be over $300, inflated by the amortization of unused plant capacity and the burdensome electrodes deal.

The next generation will have lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxide (NMC) cathodes, as used by LG, rather than the current lithium manganese oxide (LMO) chemistry. The alliance cost target is $200/kWh, whether made or bought, sources said.

With a clean slate and sufficient volume, Nissan engineers insist, their next generation of batteries could be competitive on price as well as keeping crucial know-how at the company.

"When you're developing cutting-edge technology, the best way to know about that technology is to build it in-house," said one. "That's what Tesla is doing."

Many of the past missteps can be traced to internal rivalries of the kind Ghosn is only now moving to stamp out.

Former Nissan second-in-command Carlos Tavares, racing to beat the Renault Zoe to market, cut Leaf development by a year and skipped a critical battery redesign, according to alliance veterans. Nissan later cut prices, settled a class action and offered retroactive warranties to answer customer concerns about battery deterioration. Tavares now heads PSA Peugeot Citroen.

His Renault archrival at the time, Patrick Pelata, signed a confidentiality deal with LG that meant Nissan battery engineers never even knew what they were up against.

Against that backdrop, the atmosphere may be charged when Nissan engineering boss Hideyuki Sakamoto puts final arguments against the outsourcing plan in a presentation to Ghosn as soon as this week.

But the CEO's mind may be all but made up.

"We're in the process of opening up battery sourcing to a range of suppliers," Ghosn said last week when asked whether Renault could buy batteries from France's Bolloré (>> BOLLORE).

In future some batteries will likely be outsourced "within the framework of alliance procurement", he added. "What's important to us is that electric car performance fully meets customer expectations."

(Additional reporting by Yoko Kubota in Tokyo and Gilles Guillaume in Paris; Editing by Mark Potter)

By Laurence Frost


ę Reuters 2014
Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
BOLLORÉ SE 0.63% 4.808 Real-time Quote.-2.28%
DUAL CO., LTD. 0.95% 3720 End-of-day quote.-13.79%
LG CHEM, LTD. -0.39% 505000 End-of-day quote.-17.89%
NEC CORPORATION 0.00% 5310 Delayed Quote.0.19%
NISSAN MOTOR CO LTD 3.12% 498.7 Delayed Quote.-10.99%
PANASONIC CORPORATION -0.92% 1133.5 Delayed Quote.-10.59%
PEUGEOT SA -4.21% 21.85 End-of-day quote.-2.32%
RENAULT 2.80% 24.25 Real-time Quote.-20.61%
STELLANTIS N.V. 0.34% 13.728 Delayed Quote.-18.00%
TESLA, INC. 5.14% 761.61 Delayed Quote.-31.46%
TOKYO ELECTRIC POWER COMPANY HOLDINGS, INC. 0.82% 492 Delayed Quote.68.35%
US DOLLAR / JAPANESE YEN (USD/JPY) -0.18% 129.169 Delayed Quote.12.06%
All news about LG CHEM, LTD.
05/16LG Chem, Ltd. Develops Advanced Plastic Product to Prevent Thermal Runaway in EV Batter..
CI
05/13Ontario Tories tout accelerated transmission line projects to southwest
AQ
05/12Li-Cycle Holdings Corp. announced that it has received $49.999987 million in funding fr..
CI
05/10LG Chem, KIST to Make Plastic from Carbon Dioxide
MT
05/06EXCLUSIVE : CATL planning EV battery production in United States, vetting sites - sources
RE
05/05Glencore investing $200 million in battery recycler Li-Cycle
RE
05/04Belgium's Umicore Jumps 10% Amid Interest from South Korea's LG Chem
MT
05/03LG CHEM : Biodegradable Plastic for Zero Harm to the Earth
PU
04/29UBS Adjusts LG Chem's Price Target to 860,000 Won From 940,000 Won, Keeps at Buy
MT
04/27LG Chem's Net Profit Plunges 43.9% in March Quarter; Shares Jump 3%
MT
More news
Analyst Recommendations on LG CHEM, LTD.
More recommendations
Financials
Sales 2022 48 976 B 38,6 B 38,6 B
Net income 2022 2 655 B 2,09 B 2,09 B
Net Debt 2022 7 524 B 5,93 B 5,93 B
P/E ratio 2022 14,1x
Yield 2022 2,15%
Capitalization 37 380 B 29 463 M 29 463 M
EV / Sales 2022 0,92x
EV / Sales 2023 0,84x
Nbr of Employees -
Free-Float 59,6%
Chart LG CHEM, LTD.
Duration : Period :
LG Chem, Ltd. Technical Analysis Chart | A051910 | KR7051910008 | MarketScreener
Technical analysis trends LG CHEM, LTD.
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
TrendsNeutralBearishBearish
Income Statement Evolution
Consensus
Sell
Buy
Mean consensus BUY
Number of Analysts 28
Last Close Price 505 000,00 KRW
Average target price 804 750,00 KRW
Spread / Average Target 59,4%
EPS Revisions
Managers and Directors
Hak Cheol Shin Chairman & Chief Executive Officer
Okdong Son President
Dong-Seok Cha Chief Financial Officer & Director
Ki-Soo No CTO & President-Executive Board
Young-Ho An Independent Director
Sector and Competitors