Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 


SummaryMost relevantAll NewsAnalyst Reco.Other languagesPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector newsMarketScreener Strategies

Socially responsible funds dump or rethink Facebook over data privacy

05/18/2018 | 07:16am EDT
FILE PHOTO: Facebook CEO Zuckerberg testifies before a U.S. Senate joint hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington

BOSTON (Reuters) - Several socially conscious investment firms are selling or rethinking their Facebook Inc holdings, unsatisfied by the company's moves to strengthen personal data protection and online safety after scandals involving the improper sharing of users' information.

The retreat from the world's largest social media network is one of the sharpest responses by investors to concerns about Facebook's handling of user data.

Cambridge Analytica, a now-defunct political data firm hired by Trump's 2016 election campaign, has been accused of harvesting data for 87 million Facebook users and is under investigation in the United States and Europe.

Facebook shares fell in the first quarter when the scandal broke, and recovered after founder and Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg testified before U.S. lawmakers in April. Although he deflected questions and avoided pledging to support new regulation, doubts were raised about his commitment to fully resolve the issue.

"Facebook's problems, we believe, are founded on a lack of sufficient attention to consumer privacy and data security, compounded by inadequate governance," wrote Adam Kanzer, vice president of Domini Funds, in a May 8 letter to Facebook explaining its plan to sell its 111,000 Facebook shares held in the Domini Impact Equity Fund.

In April Eaton Vance Corp unit Calvert Research and Management also sold Facebook shares on concerns about lax controls that meant "the company clearly violated users' fundamental right to privacy," contrary to the firm's investment principles, according to Emma Doner, one of its Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) analysts.

The divestment by the two well-known firms build on previous concerns by other so-called ESG managers, which consider social responsibility when buying stocks.

Others may follow. Joe Keefe, president of Pax World Funds, said Facebook's place in investment vehicles like the Pax ESG Beta Dividend Fund will be reviewed with an eye on recent controversies that "may very well affect the company's scores and its eligibility for continued inclusion in those portfolios."

A Facebook spokeswoman declined to comment.

Zuckerberg controls a majority of Facebook's voting power, but must face shareholders at its annual meeting on May 31. Top proxy advisers have recommended a number of votes contrary to the board's positions.

ESG funds represent just a small fraction of Facebook shares, but their moves may influence top investors including BlackRock Inc and Vanguard Group, which have paid more attention to social issues in recent years. Representatives for both declined to comment.

Facebook had already faced scepticism from ESG funds which on average had kept the company at a market-neutral weighting of 1.7 percent, according to Morningstar data, likely tied to Facebook's average score from ESG rating service Sustainalytics.

Martin Kremenstein, senior managing director at Nuveen, said one reason it would be hard for the company's socially minded funds to own Facebook is because the problems occurred despite a settlement the company struck with the Federal Trade Commission in 2011, which included a pledge to improve privacy protections.

Referring to the latest revelations involving Cambridge Analytica, he said, "This is a bigger scandal than before, but it's not a new one."

Not all ESG managers aim to divest. Lauren Compere of Boston Common Asset Management said Facebook remains attractive given its strong growth and cash generation, and said the company deserved credit for steps like fighting unreasonable government requests for users' information.

Julie Goodridge of NorthStar Asset Management, with about 36,900 Facebook shares, said managers should keep their shares and vote in support of upcoming proxy resolutions like one from her firm calling for Facebook to give all shares an equal vote, which would reduce Zuckerberg's power.

(Reporting by Ross Kerber; Editing by Peter Henderson and Richard Chang)

By Ross Kerber

ę Reuters 2018
Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
BLACKROCK, INC. 0.99% 869.83 Delayed Quote.19.45%
EATON CORPORATION PLC 1.34% 157.61 Delayed Quote.29.97%
FACEBOOK INC -4.23% 357.61 Delayed Quote.36.65%
JUST GROUP PLC 3.65% 102.1 Delayed Quote.40.92%
LETS HOLDINGS GROUP CO., LTD. 0.32% 6.22 End-of-day quote.-20.05%
LOOK HOLDINGS INCORPORATED 0.28% 1412 End-of-day quote.47.54%
WILL GROUP, INC. 1.02% 988 End-of-day quote.-1.79%
All news about BLACKROCK, INC.
07/28MARKET CHATTER : Lloyds Banking Reportedly Reaches Deal to Acquire Embark for 40..
07/28NOKIAN TYRES : Disclosure under chapter 9, section 10 of the securities market a..
07/27NESTE OYJ : Notification under Chapter 9, Section 10 of the Finnish Securities M..
07/27Psiquantum Corp. announced that it has received $450 million in funding from ..
07/26SECTOR UPDATE : Energy Stocks Extending Gains After Crude Oil Pares Earlier Loss..
07/26SECTOR UPDATE : Energy Stocks Rising Despite Monday Fall in Crude Oil Prices
07/26NOTIFICATION UNDER CHAPTER 9, SECTIO : direct and indirect holdings of BlackRock..
07/23BLACKROCK : Insider at BlackRock (BLK) Makes Significant Sale of Stock
07/23BLACKROCK : Amendments to articles of incorporation/bylaws/change in fiscal year..
07/23BLACKROCK INC. : Amendments to Articles of Inc. or Bylaws; Change in Fiscal Year..
More news
Financials (USD)
Sales 2021 19 283 M - -
Net income 2021 5 733 M - -
Net cash 2021 3 643 M - -
P/E ratio 2021 23,0x
Yield 2021 1,89%
Capitalization 131 B 131 B -
EV / Sales 2021 6,61x
EV / Sales 2022 5,93x
Nbr of Employees 16 700
Free-Float 87,6%
Duration : Period :
BlackRock, Inc. Technical Analysis Chart | BLK | US09247X1019 | MarketScreener
Technical analysis trends BLACKROCK, INC.
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 14
Last Close Price 860,71 $
Average target price 974,58 $
Spread / Average Target 13,2%
EPS Revisions
Managers and Directors
Laurence Douglas Fink Chairman & Chief Executive Officer
Robert Steven Kapito President & Non-Independent Director
Gary S. Shedlin Chief Financial Officer & Senior Managing Director
Derek N. Stein Global Head-Business Operations & Technology
Robert L. Goldstein Chief Operating Officer & Senior Managing Director
Sector and Competitors