Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 

MarketScreener Homepage  >  Equities  >  Euronext Paris  >  Veolia Environnement    VIE   FR0000124141


SummaryMost relevantAll NewsAnalyst Reco.Other languagesPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector newsMarketScreener Strategies

Veolia's Suez Stake Acquisition Explained

11/27/2020 | 09:45am EST

By Joshua Kirby

Veolia Environnement SA's deal to buy a 29.9% stake in Suez SA from Engie SA has been in the works since late August, but the process has been anything but smooth.

French waste-and-water-management company Veolia bought the stake in its peer from energy company Engie with its second bid. But Suez has been opposed from the beginning and a legal wrangle has ensued. On Nov. 19, court bailiffs seized documents from the offices of Veolia and Engie, as well as investment firm Meridiam, as part of a court order requested by Suez.


August 2020

At the end of August, Veolia launched an initial bid for the 29.9% stake at 15.50 euros ($18.47) a share. Engie had previously initiated a strategic review that included a possible sale of its Suez stake, which meant Veolia's bid was considered likely to succeed.

Analysts at Bryan Garnier said that it made sense for Engie to divest its Suez stake as part of wider streamlining, and that the acquisition would boost Veolia's international profile.

September 2020

Suez, however, was opposed from the beginning of the deal. Management expressed its opposition to Veolia's approach in September, characterizing the bid as "hostile." Suez said the offer undervalued the company, and that it had concerns over antitrust issues and potential job cuts.

On Sept. 17, Engie said it wouldn't accept the offer under the initial terms, but would be open to an improved offer. As expected, on Sept. 30, Veolia increased its bid to EUR18 a share, valuing the 29.9% stake at around EUR3.4 billion.

October 2020

On Oct. 5, Veolia said Engie had accepted the offer. As part of the offer, Veolia would guarantee job security for all Suez employees in France, while Meridiam would acquire Suez's French water-activities arm to preserve competition after analysts raised the prospect of potential antitrust issues.

Suez continued to oppose the deal, warning of "several serious anomalies" in the bid in a letter to French Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire. It also voiced support for a rival bid from private-equity firm Ardian, which had expressed interest in buying the stake from Engie.

A twist came on Oct. 9, when a French court ordered the suspension of the stake purchase. The legal reasoning behind the suspension, requested by Suez, was that the company's social and economic committees hadn't been consulted over the deal. Veolia called the decision "incomprehensible" and "grotesque," arguing that only Suez management had the capability to organize such a consultation, and that its failure to do so was born of its opposition to the deal. Veolia said it would appeal the decision.

November 2020

Early in November, Veolia confirmed that it still intended to make a full takeover bid for Suez, offering the same EUR18 a share price for the remaining share capital. It said the bid would be launched when the Suez board of directors showed itself amenable. Suez responded by noting the lack of a takeover offer to date, saying the only approach had been via media reports. Suez stressed that any takeover offer would have to reflect the company's value, as well as set out the detail of the combination and any asset sales.

In an apparent further setback, Suez said on Nov. 19 that the Paris Court of Appeal had confirmed the earlier decision suspending the effects of the stake purchase. Since no committee consultation had been carried out before the deal was finalized on Oct. 5, the effects of the sale remained suspended until that took place, according to the ruling, Suez said. "Effects" in this context seems mostly to refer to the voting rights conferred on Veolia as holder of a stake in Suez. The company added that it had not received the necessary information from either Veolia or Engie to carry out the relevant employee consultations.

For its part, Veolia insisted that Suez had told the court that it had finalized the consultation on Nov. 5, and that since the consultation period was three months, it would recover all its rights relating to the stake purchase on Feb. 5 at the latest. Suez, however, disputed this, arguing that the starting date for the consultation hadn't been fixed.

The legal developments took a further twist on Nov. 26, when court bailiffs entered the offices of Engie, Veolia and investment firm Meridiam to seize documents relating to the deal, according to media reports. According to the reports, the court order was requested by Suez, which apparently suspected collusion between Veolia, Engie and Meridiam. Suez is also said to suspect that Meridiam's purchase of Suez Eau was agreed as early as July, even before Engie Chairman Jean-Pierre Clamadieu announced the company was considering selling its stake in Suez.

What's Ahead

Not only do the bones of contention remain unresolved, there isn't yet any agreement between the parties as to when they will be. Veolia says early February is the latest possible end to the consultation period Suez is insisting on; Suez disagrees. If and when these issues are resolved, Veolia will launch a full takeover bid for its peer.

As for the document seizure, Veolia, Engie and Meridiam have the right to request a counter-judgment to the court order, in which case the documents seized would be held pending further legal developments, according to French law.

Write to Joshua Kirby at Joshua.Kirby@dowjones.com

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

11-27-20 0944ET

Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
ELECTRICITÉ DE FRANCE -0.67% 10.38 Real-time Quote.-18.96%
ENGIE 2.55% 13.05 Real-time Quote.1.68%
SUEZ SA 0.26% 17.105 Real-time Quote.5.15%
VEOLIA ENVIRONNEMENT 3.15% 22.57 Real-time Quote.9.35%
01/27Veolia to Legally Oppose Sale of Suez Strategic Assets
01/26VEOLIA ENVIRONNEMENT : Will Oppose Any Sale of Suez Strategic Assets Opposing It..
01/26VEOLIA ENVIRONNEMENT : PR - Veolia will oppose any sale of Suez strategic assets..
01/25SUEZ : Veolia's target Suez says second half revenue, profits to exceed expectat..
01/18Veolia CEO wants to talk with Suez as government favours friendly solution
01/18VEOLIA ENVIRONNEMENT : PR - Veolia will not sell its 29.9%
01/18Veolia CEO wants to talk with Suez as government favours friendly solution
01/18European stocks end higher as Stellantis, luxury stocks jump
01/18Suez shares bolstered as funds propose alternative to Veolia bid
01/18VEOLIA ENVIRONNEMENT : Paris Court Declares No Jurisdiction Over Consultation Pr..
More news
Sales 2020 25 947 M 31 373 M 31 373 M
Net income 2020 365 M 442 M 442 M
Net Debt 2020 11 191 M 13 531 M 13 531 M
P/E ratio 2020 28,2x
Yield 2020 3,25%
Capitalization 12 379 M 14 974 M 14 968 M
EV / Sales 2020 0,91x
EV / Sales 2021 0,86x
Nbr of Employees 171 212
Free-Float 95,5%
Duration : Period :
Veolia Environnement Technical Analysis Chart | VIE | FR0000124141 | MarketScreener
Technical analysis trends VEOLIA ENVIRONNEMENT
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 11
Average target price 23,94 €
Last Close Price 21,88 €
Spread / Highest target 41,2%
Spread / Average Target 9,39%
Spread / Lowest Target -15,4%
EPS Revisions
Managers and Directors
Antoine Frérot Chairman & Chief Executive Officer
Estelle Karine Brachlianoff Chief Operating Officer
Claude Olivier Francois Laruelle Chief Financial Officer
Christophe Nebon Director-Technical & Performance
Didier Bove CIO, Senior VP-Information Systems & Technology