Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 

MarketScreener Homepage  >  Equities  >  London Stock Exchange  >  Smith & Nephew Plc    SN.   GB0009223206


SummaryMost relevantAll NewsPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector newsAnalyst Recommendations

U.S. Supreme Court to hear challenge to influential patent court

10/13/2020 | 10:02am EST

WASHINGTON, Oct 13 (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court on Tuesday agreed to decide whether more than 100 technology disputes must be reheard because judges were unconstitutionally appointed to a U.S. Patent and Trademark Office tribunal in a case arising from a medical device patent challenge.

The justices said they would review a 2019 lower court decision that found a "constitutional defect" in how Patent Trial and Appeal Board judges are appointed. That ruling came in an appeal by privately held Florida-based medical device company Arthrex of a patent tribunal three-judge panel's decision that invalidated part of one of its patents that had been challenged by British-based rival Smith & Nephew PLC.

The tribunal, created by Congress in 2011, is an administrative court run by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office and it takes a second look at patents issued by the agency and often cancels them, much to the dismay of some inventors.

The tribunal has proven popular with big technology companies such as Apple Inc and Alphabet Inc's Google LLC, which often ask it to cancel patents they have been sued for violating. Litigation before the tribunal is seen by many companies as a more efficient alternative to resolving cases in federal court.

Unlike U.S. District Courts, the tribunal has more than 200 judges who are government employees appointed by the U.S. commerce secretary rather than nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which specializes in patent litigation, ruled that these tribunal judges have considerable power and autonomy, making them the sort of "principal officers" who must be appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate under the U.S. Constitution.

To remedy this constitutional problem, the Federal Circuit struck down part of a law dealing with how these tribunal judges can be removed from power.

The court's remedy allowed the board to continue operating. Still, the Federal Circuit has said that more than 100 technology disputes may need to be reheard before new panels of tribunal judges.

Arthrex, Smith & Nephew and the U.S. government all appealed the Federal Circuit's decision to the Supreme Court. U.S. government lawyers have argued that the patent office's director, who was Senate confirmed, directs and supervises tribunal judges so they are not "principal officers" requiring Senate approval. (Reporting by Jan Wolfe; editing by Grant McCool)

© Reuters 2020
Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
ALPHABET INC. 2.33% 1795.36 Delayed Quote.34.04%
APPLE INC. 3.08% 122.72 Delayed Quote.62.17%
SMITH & NEPHEW PLC 4.50% 1511 Delayed Quote.-17.74%
All news about SMITH & NEPHEW PLC
11/23SMITH & NEPHEW : SCOTUS To Decide Constitutionality Of PTAB Judge Appointments
11/20SMITH & NEPHEW : Investor presentation October - December 2020
11/20SMITH & NEPHEW : What Arthrex Could Mean For The PTAB Going Forward
11/18SMITH & NEPHEW : New data shows Smith+Nephew's NOVOSTITCH Meniscal Repair System..
11/13ARTHREX : Who Are You Calling Inferior?
11/06SMITH & NEPHEW : +Nephew adds patient selection and care-pathway optimization to..
10/31SMITH & NEPHEW PLC : Monthly statement on outstanding equity shares and voting r..
10/29SMITH & NEPHEW : +Nephew revenue lifted by recovery in elective surgery demand
10/29SMITH & NEPHEW : 3Q Underlying Revenue Improved After Virus Hit
10/29SMITH & NEPHEW : +Nephew Third Quarter 2020 Trading Report
More news
Financials (USD)
Sales 2020 4 694 M - -
Net income 2020 389 M - -
Net Debt 2020 1 633 M - -
P/E ratio 2020 47,5x
Yield 2020 1,43%
Capitalization 17 682 M 17 692 M -
EV / Sales 2020 4,11x
EV / Sales 2021 3,57x
Nbr of Employees 17 500
Free-Float 98,7%
Duration : Period :
Smith & Nephew Plc Technical Analysis Chart | SN. | GB0009223206 | MarketScreener
Technical analysis trends SMITH & NEPHEW PLC
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus HOLD
Number of Analysts 16
Average target price 21,58 $
Last Close Price 20,23 $
Spread / Highest target 32,6%
Spread / Average Target 6,68%
Spread / Lowest Target -34,1%
EPS Revisions
Roland D. Diggelmann Chief Executive Officer & Non-Executive Director
Roberto Quarta Chairman
Mark Gladwell President-Global Operations & Business Services
Anne-Francoise Nesmes Chief Financial Officer & Executive Director
Vasant Padmanabhan President-Research & Development
Sector and Competitors