Log in
E-mail
Password
Show password
Remember
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Settings
Settings
Dynamic quotes 
OFFON
News: Latest News
Latest NewsCompaniesMarketsEconomy & ForexCommoditiesInterest RatesBusiness LeadersFinance Pro.CalendarSectors 
All NewsEconomyCurrencies & ForexEconomic EventsCryptocurrenciesCybersecurityPress Releases

Five reasons the ECB didn't follow the Fed on inflation

07/08/2021 | 01:10pm EDT
FILE PHOTO: European Central Bank President Christine Lagarde in Brussels, Belgium

FRANKFURT (Reuters) - Setting out a policy strategy shift on Thursday, the European Central Bank left many questions unanswered but made one point abundantly clear: it would not follow its U.S. counterpart in targeting an average level of inflation.

The fact that it put distance between the two regimes in such a stark way reflects both the ECB's own struggles and the U.S. Federal Reserve's difficulty in communicating how average inflation-targeting actually works and impacts policy.

The following are five takeaways on why the ECB did not copy the Fed.

POLITICS

Average inflation-targeting means making an explicit commitment to overshooting your target after missing it for a longer period. That would be a big no-no for inflation-wary Germany, the region's largest economy.

ECB President Christine Lagarde said a temporary overshoot might happen and in some situations the ECB would put in place policies that resulted in such a swing. But that is still not a goal and falls short of the Fed's overshoot commitment.

This may be seen as a victory for Bundesbank chief Jens Weidmann who has persistently rejected the idea of shooting for price growth above the target.

"Are we doing average inflation-targeting like the Fed? The answer is no, very squarely," Lagarde told a news conference

BIGGER

The ECB's own inflation misses have been much bigger than the Fed's, so getting an average would mean bigger overshoots.

Last year's inflation averaged just 0.3%, well below the ECB's 2% target, while in 2019, before the coronavirus pandemic, inflation was 1.2%.

Offsetting these is all but impossible. It would mean huge overshoots with a nearly depleted policy arsenal, a combination that would challenge the ECB's credibility. Even if there was policy space for such swing, political opposition would be overwhelming. Moreover, gyrations on such a scale would not be healthy for an economy.

FLEXIBILITY

The ECB has tailored its entire strategy towards flexibility. It targets inflation over a medium term, an undefined, vague concept, while its tolerance for deviations is similarly loosely worded to give the Governing Council maximum flexibility.

The bank's guidance on future policy moves is also imprecise, so moving to a Fed-style average would actually reduce that cherished flexibility.

MESSY

Targeting average inflation over a period is messy. It requires the central bank to define a time period and a specific inflation measure it looks at.

Markets then hold the central bank accountable and price assets accordingly. Such a framework either reduces the ECB's flexibility or, if it does not specify the terms of the framework, will leave markets confused, causing asset price volatility.

THE FED'S STRUGGLES

The Fed's own difficulties also dissuaded the ECB.

The Fed decided on Flexible Average Inflation Targeting last August but has been widely criticised for not defining how much of an overshoot would be allowed over what length of time.

A year later the picture is still not clear. In fact, different inflation forecasts and different sensitivities to inflation risk have left a broad division among policymakers. Some see rate increases already next year while some expect the first move only in 2024.

(Reporting by Balazs Koranyi; Additional reporting by Howard Schneider in Washington; editing by Mark John and John Stonestreet)


ę Reuters 2021
Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
AUSTRALIAN DOLLAR / EURO (AUD/EUR) 0.03% 0.61916 Delayed Quote.-1.68%
BRITISH POUND / EURO (GBP/EUR) -0.02% 1.16454 Delayed Quote.4.61%
CANADIAN DOLLAR / EURO (CAD/EUR) 0.05% 0.666378 Delayed Quote.3.77%
INDIAN RUPEE / EURO (INR/EUR) 0.03% 0.011578 Delayed Quote.3.25%
US DOLLAR / EURO (USD/EUR) -0.07% 0.852217 Delayed Quote.4.13%
Latest news "Economy & Forex"
05:50pWall Street extends global slump on China fears
RE
05:48pUtilities Shares Fall But Beat Broader Market Amid Shift to Safety -- Utilities Roundup
DJ
05:46pCommunications Services Shares Move Lower -- Communications Services Roundup
DJ
05:40pTechnology Shares Fall Amid Risk-Off Trade -- Tech Roundup
DJ
05:38pThe WSJ Dollar Index Rises 0.04% to 87.83 -- Data Talk
DJ
05:38pEuro Gains 0.02% to $1.1729 -- Data Talk
DJ
05:38pSterling Lost 0.58% to $1.3658 -- Data Talk
DJ
05:37pTwo key u.s. senators urge justice department to investigate, prosecute unruly air passenger cases -letter
RE
05:37pDollar Lost 0.53% to 109.41 Yen -- Data Talk
DJ
05:37pFinancial Shares Tumble Amid China Property Concerns -- Financials Roundup
DJ
Latest news "Economy & Forex"